Bay Island Homes on Siesta Key

Bay Island Homes for Sale on Siesta Key

City

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Price Range

Save Search

Sort by:

Price, high to low

$12,500,000

546 Freeling Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 5 Beds 7 Baths 4,353 SqFt 8 DOM Residential MLS® # A4682396

$9,900,000

684 Freeling Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 3 Beds 4 Baths 2,548 SqFt 83 DOM Residential MLS® # A4675752

$8,395,000

3820 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 4 Beds 6 Baths 4,775 SqFt 99 DOM Residential MLS® # A4673215

$7,749,000

3460 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 5 Beds 8 Baths 6,030 SqFt 12 DOM Residential MLS® # A4683051

Open House

$5,995,000

↓ $455,000

3550 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 4 Beds 6 Baths 4,711 SqFt 666 DOM Residential

Open House

Fri, Mar 13th, 2026 @ 10am - 3:30pm

MLS® # A4610537

$5,825,000

527 Freeling Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND SHORES 4 Beds 5 Baths 4,310 SqFt 87 DOM Residential MLS® # A4669657

$5,100,000

831 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 5 Beds 5 Baths 4,250 SqFt 89 DOM Residential MLS® # A4674955

$4,950,000

3607 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND SHORES 4 Beds 4 Baths 3,876 SqFt 162 DOM Residential MLS® # A4662402

$4,190,000

838 Norsota Way, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 5 Beds 7 Baths 3,001 SqFt 30 DOM Residential MLS® # A4682092

$2,999,000

↓ $201,000

428 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 2 Beds 2 Baths 2,163 SqFt 201 DOM Residential MLS® # A4661294

$2,995,000

↓ $505,000

732 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND SHORES 3 Beds 5 Baths 3,743 SqFt 376 DOM Residential MLS® # A4640849

$1,599,000

763 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 4 Beds 3 Baths 2,294 SqFt 272 DOM Residential MLS® # A4648764

Open House

$1,499,000

↓ $1,000

3446 Anglin Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND PARK 4 Beds 3 Baths 3,064 SqFt 35 DOM Residential

Open House

Sat, Mar 14th, 2026 @ 12am - 2pm

MLS® # A4680766

$1,399,000

↓ $100,000

854 Norsota Way, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 2 Beds 2 Baths 1,667 SqFt 170 DOM Residential MLS® # A4665123

$949,900

617 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA

BAY ISLAND 4 Beds 4 Baths 2,709 SqFt 86 DOM Residential MLS® # A4675302

Bay Island Homes 

Bay Island on Siesta Key is located on the northern end of Siesta Key just after you cross the Siesta Drive Bridge which is the northern bridge onto Siesta Key. When you first cross the bridge you have actually crossed onto "Bay Island" before you then pass over a small bridge onto the Island of Siesta Key.  Bay Island as you will see on the map below includes the streets of Flamingo Ave., Freeling Drive,  Hamilton Ave., Seagrove Drive, Anglin Drive, Norsota Way, and the north part of Siesta Drive coming from the mainland of Sarasota before it becomes Higel Ave.  Bay Island on Siesta Key is comprised of 169 single family homes many of which are waterfront homes with very quick access to the ICW, Sarasota Bay, and the  aqua blue waters of the Gulf of Mexico.  The waterfront homes on Bay Island enjoy magnificent views of the Sarasota Bay, the ICW, and the skyline of Sarasota.  If we can be of any assistance in helping you find a home on Bay Island or any other neighborhood on Siesta Key please feel comfortable in contacting us. 

Interested in learning more about the homes in Siesta Key? Contact us online or call 941-586-4790 for more information about buying and selling a home in Siesta Key and other communities in the Sarasota area. 

 Siesta Key Homes             Siesta Key Condos

Back to the Top