A Florida Retreat

Casey Key

Casey Key is a narrow 8 mile long Island that is located just 15 miles south of downtown Sarasota and just a few miles north of the city of Venice. Although popularized because of its beauty and renowned for its waterfront homes, Casey Key still feels like a hidden treasure to the residents that are lucky enough to call it home.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $6.5M
Lowest Price $2.8M
Highest Price $18.5M
Total Listings 15
Avg. Days On Market 145
Avg. Price/SQFT $1.8K

Property Types (active listings)

Casey Key Homes and Land for Sale

Click the links below to sort results by price range.
All Listings Over $1,000,000
Sort by:
New
1604 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,500,000

1604 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 2 Beds 2 Baths 1,940 SqFt 0 DOM Residential MLS® # N6125025
New
2555 Casey Key Rd, NOKOMIS

$12,000,000

2555 Casey Key Rd, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 6 Baths 5,414 SqFt 3 DOM Residential MLS® # A4558745
2800 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,000,000

2800 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 3 Baths 3,302 SqFt 45 DOM Residential MLS® # A4555150
5 North Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$4,950,000

5 North Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 4 Baths 2,380 SqFt 75 DOM Residential MLS® # U8183072
608 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$6,900,000

↓ $850,000

608 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 3 Baths 3,086 SqFt 77 DOM Residential MLS® # A4552859
3000 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,250,000

↓ $250,000

3000 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 92 DOM Land MLS® # A4551377
4005 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,680,000

4005 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 94 DOM Land MLS® # N6123734
476 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$7,250,000

↓ $345,000

476 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 4 Baths 4,740 SqFt 105 DOM Residential MLS® # N6123485
615-621 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$13,000,000

615-621 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 6 Beds 6 Baths 3,414 SqFt 143 DOM Residential MLS® # A4546715
3214-3216 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$5,950,000

↓ $250,000

3214-3216 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 4 Baths 4,935 SqFt 147 DOM Residential MLS® # A4547431
3760 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$5,250,000

↓ $500,000

3760 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 4 Baths 5,053 SqFt 172 DOM Residential MLS® # A4545093
512 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$5,950,000

↓ $550,000

512 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 6 Baths 5,141 SqFt 178 DOM Residential MLS® # A4544000
3727 Sandspur Lane, NOKOMIS

$2,995,000

↓ $255,000

3727 Sandspur Lane, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 2 Baths 2,001 SqFt 177 DOM Residential MLS® # A4543357
3214 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$2,800,000

↓ $400,000

3214 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 4 Baths 4,935 SqFt 189 DOM Residential MLS® # A4542528
4004 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,000,000

↓ $450,000

4004 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 4 Baths 2,188 SqFt 232 DOM Residential MLS® # A4534806
1312 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$18,500,000

↓ $1,500,000

1312 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 6 Beds 8 Baths 11,785 SqFt 279 DOM Residential MLS® # A4533327
3999 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,700,000

3999 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 2 Beds 2 Baths 954 SqFt 332 DOM Residential MLS® # N6119928

Casey Key Real Estate Info

Casey Key is home to fewer than 500 residents who enjoy a private and quiet old Florida charm lifestyle.

The Island of Casey Key has become an island retreat with a mix of Florida style beach bungalows nestled between large elegant waterfront mansions.

To own a Casey Key Home is to enjoy miles of pristine sugary white beaches with views of the aqua-blue waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Because of this, the Casey Key real estate market has become one of the most prestigious addresses in all of Florida, now called home to celebrities, artists, prominent business owners, sports figures, movie stars, and famous authors such as Stephen King.

With the Gulf of Mexico on the west side of Casey Key and the bay on the east side of the Island, the majority of the homes on Casey Key are waterfront homes. Because Casey Key is a very narrow island in many spots, many of the Casey Key waterfront homes enjoy a view or contain property on both the Gulf of Mexico and the Bay. It is not unusual for a Casey Key waterfront home to have a beach view of the sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico in the front of the home, while having your boat docked in your backyard on the bayside of the island.

Casey Key Homes for sale can range in price from $700,000 to over $12,000,000.

Interested in learning more about Casey Key real estate? Contact us online or call 941-586-4790 for more information about buying and selling a home in Casey Key and other communities in the Sarasota area.

Casey Key Community & Area

Access to Casey Key is from two different bridges, which also connect the residents here to surrounding communities.

The north bridge crosses onto Casey Key at Blackburn Point Road from route 41 in Nokomis. This bridge at Blackburn Point is a one lane swing bridge constructed in 1920 and is one of only a few in the US. The south bridge crosses onto Casey Key from Albee Road and is a conventional drawbridge. Both bridges bring you directly onto Casey Key Road which runs across the entire Island.

Casey Key has several very unique casual waterfront restaurants and motels. As you cross the one lane swing bridge at Blackburn Point you notice directly to your left the large tiki hut. This is the Casey Key Tiki Bar and it shares the parking lot with the Casey Key Fish House, which is a casual waterfront dining restaurant. Both of these Casey Key landmarks are accessible by car or by boat and are a very popular and welcome spot for locals and visitors.

If you are a boater this is a must stop spot just after going under the Blackburn Point bridge.

The hotels for Casey Key are located off of the south Albee Road bridge near the Casey Key Beach which is also known as the Nokomis Beach. The beach has lifeguards, restrooms, and a snack bar.

If you continue south on South Casey Key Road you will come to the end of Casey Key which is the Jetty Park where you can see boats coming in and out of the Venice Inlet.ccBelow is the current list of all the available Casey Key homes for sale.

This list is updated daily with prices, descriptions, photos and virtual tours.  If you are interested in viewing any of these listings please call me, Sara at (941) 586-4790 or email me directly at Sara@SaraSellsSarasota.com and I would be happy to arrange a time to personally show you these homes and answer any of your questions.

To stay up-to-date on all the latest Sarasota real estate listings, sign up with Sara Sells Sarasota now. We have listings for Siesta Key Condos, Longboat Key Condos, Lido Key Condos, Sarasota neighborhoods, golf course homes, land for salefeatured properties, and so much more for sale.


                                                                                                                      Back to the Top of this Page

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search