A Florida Retreat

Casey Key

Nestled along the sun-drenched coastline of Florida's Gulf, Casey Key graces the shores with its slender, 8-mile stretch. Positioned merely 15 miles south of the vibrant pulse of downtown Sarasota and a brief jaunt north of the enchanting city of Venice, this secluded paradise captures hearts with its breathtaking vistas and coveted waterfront abodes. Casey Key, known for its exclusivity, captivates those privileged enough to call it home. This coastal haven seamlessly blends natural splendor and coastal sophistication.


READ MORE

Casey Key Real Estate Stats

Average Price $6.4M
Lowest Price $2M
Highest Price $12M
Total Listings 18
Avg. Days On Market 182
Avg. Price/SQFT $1.8K

Property Types (active listings)

Search Casey Key, FL Homes for Sale

Click the links below to sort results by price range.
All Listings Over $1,000,000
Sort by:
New
507 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$11,795,000

507 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 7 Baths 6,596 SqFt 3 DOM Residential MLS® # A4600753
5 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$4,750,000

5 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 4 Baths 2,380 SqFt 9 DOM Residential MLS® # U8231292
Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$1,980,000

Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 14 DOM Land MLS® # A4598662
3801 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$8,500,000

3801 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 5 Baths 4,112 SqFt 14 DOM Residential MLS® # A4598511
1210 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$2,140,000

1210 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 3 Baths 2,784 SqFt 35 DOM Residential MLS® # A4596532
929 Casey Cove Drive, NOKOMIS

$3,995,000

↓ $255,000

929 Casey Cove Drive, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 4 Baths 3,735 SqFt 48 DOM Residential MLS® # A4592977
1544 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$10,500,000

1544 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 6 Beds 8 Baths 6,997 SqFt 80 DOM Residential MLS® # A4591939
4020 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$2,000,000

4020 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 82 DOM Land MLS® # A4591526
2821 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$11,900,000

↓ $600,000

2821 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 6 Baths 6,891 SqFt 96 DOM Residential MLS® # A4589953
2812 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,150,000

↓ $100,000

2812 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 3 Baths 2,809 SqFt 113 DOM Residential MLS® # A4588309
2410 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,795,000

↓ $100,000

2410 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 2 Beds 2 Baths 1,186 SqFt 125 DOM Residential MLS® # A4586886
426 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$4,900,000

426 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 2 Baths 1,876 SqFt 157 DOM Residential MLS® # A4583445
1704 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$5,200,000

↓ $300,000

1704 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 5 Baths 6,435 SqFt 234 DOM Residential MLS® # A4574918
3909 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$7,950,000

↓ $650,000

3909 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 6 Baths 6,335 SqFt 338 DOM Residential MLS® # A4563073
4019 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$9,500,000

↓ $500,000

4019 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 4 Beds 6 Baths 6,725 SqFt 344 DOM Residential MLS® # A4562025
Casey Key Rd, NOKOMIS

$12,000,000

Casey Key Rd, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 5 Beds 6 Baths 5,414 SqFt 391 DOM Residential MLS® # A4558745
476 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

$6,872,900

↓ $125,000

476 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY

CASEY KEY 3 Beds 4 Baths 4,740 SqFt 493 DOM Residential MLS® # N6123485
3999 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

$3,997,000

↑ $297,000

3999 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS

CASEY KEY 2 Beds 2 Baths 954 SqFt 720 DOM Residential MLS® # N6119928

Casey Key Real Estate Info

Tucked away amidst the allure of Casey Key resides an intimate community of fewer than 500 residents, offering an exclusive lifestyle steeped in the tranquil charm of old Florida. This enclave comprises an eclectic blend of residences; from charming Florida-style beach bungalows harmoniously nestled between elegant waterfront mansions, each home exudes its unique coastal charisma.

Owning a property on Casey Key presents residents with exclusive access to miles of unspoiled, sugar-white beaches. Here, the azure waters of the Gulf of Mexico gently lap against the shore, offering a panoramic canvas of natural beauty to behold.

Regarded as one of Florida's most coveted addresses, Casey Key magnetizes an eclectic mix of personalities, drawing in celebrities, artists, prominent business moguls, sports figures, Hollywood stars, and revered authors like Stephen King.

The allure of this island's captivating ambiance lies in its diverse geography, with homes predominantly positioned as waterfront properties. The slender width of the island often grants many residences panoramic views or direct access to both the Gulf and the Bay, presenting a singular blend of coastal living.

Homes on Casey Key encapsulate a spectrum of luxury, ranging from approximately $700,000 to upwards of $12,000,000. Among these prized real estate offerings are opulent custom Gulf-front estates, featuring grand double arched doors, soaring ceilings, and sweeping panoramic views that stretch across the horizon.

Modern architectural marvels grace the landscape, appearing as contemporary masterpieces against the vivid blue sky. With thoughtfully designed open floor plans, these homes seamlessly fuse entertainment spaces with serene waterfront vistas, epitomizing the pinnacle of coastal luxury living.


Our list of Casey Key homes is updated daily with prices, descriptions, photos and virtual tours. If you're interested in learning more, contact us online or call 941-586-4790 for more information about buying and selling a home in Casey Key and other communities in the Sarasota area.

Casey Key Highlights & Amenities

The bridges leading onto Casey Key not only provide access but also serve as iconic gateways into this coastal retreat. The Blackburn Point swing bridge, a rare gem constructed in 1920, narrates tales of yesteryears with its nostalgic charm, while the Albee Road drawbridge seamlessly connects the island to the neighboring mainland, painting a scenic passage across the picturesque waters.

Alongside its charming bridges, Casey Key is adorned with distinctive waterfront establishments, adding character to its tranquil ambiance. The legendary Casey Key Tiki Bar and the neighboring Casey Key Fish House beckon patrons to unwind by the waterfront, offering more than just delightful dining experiences—here, time seems to stand still, inviting visitors to savor moments of serenity amidst the coastal vibes.

The island's allure extends beyond its dining spots; it's a playground for water enthusiasts. Kayakers and paddleboarders revel in the calm waters of the bay, while fishing enthusiasts find solace in the plentiful fishing spots dotting the coastline. The calm and clear waters are an invitation for snorkeling adventures, unveiling a world teeming with marine life just beneath the surface.

Nearby attractions complement the tranquility of Casey Key with bursts of cultural vibrancy. The nearby city of Venice, with its historic downtown and European-inspired architecture, captivates visitors with its eclectic boutiques, art galleries, and vibrant cultural scene. The Venice Theatre, a cornerstone of the city's cultural heritage, stages captivating performances year-round, inviting residents to immerse themselves in the arts.

Nature enthusiasts find solace in the picturesque beauty of Oscar Scherer State Park, a short distance from Casey Key. This scenic parkland, a haven for hiking and birdwatching, invites residents to embrace the untouched wilderness and bask in the serenity of nature's embrace.

Casey Key, Sarasota FAQs

What makes Casey Key an exclusive destination in Sarasota?

Casey Key stands out for its secluded and upscale residential environment. It offers privacy, stunning waterfront views, and luxurious properties that attract those seeking an affluent coastal lifestyle.

Are public beaches accessible on Casey Key?

No, Casey Key is primarily residential, and the beaches are privately owned. However, Nokomis Beach, located nearby, is a public beach that provides access to the public for swimming, sunbathing, and other recreational activities.

What architectural styles dominate the residences on Casey Key?

Homes on Casey Key feature an array of architectural styles, including Mediterranean, modern, contemporary, and Old Florida designs. This diversity caters to different tastes and preferences of potential buyers.

Are there any community-specific amenities available on Casey Key?

Casey Key maintains a serene and exclusive atmosphere with minimal commercial development. However, residents enjoy private beachfronts, boat docks, and access to water-based activities, fostering a tranquil yet active lifestyle.

Is living on Casey Key convenient for accessing Sarasota's city life?

Absolutely! While Casey Key offers privacy and tranquility, it's conveniently close to Sarasota's cultural attractions, dining venues, shopping centers, and entertainment options, allowing residents to enjoy the best of both worlds.

BACK TO TOP
                                                                                                                 

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search